|

Top Dog Subscription Boxes That Your Pooch Will Love!

If you’ve ever come home with a “special” toy or treat for your pup and watched them lose their mind with excitement, a dog subscription box is basically that feeling… on repeat. Every month! In this post, we’ll dive deep into how dog subscription boxes work, who they’re best for, and some of the top dog subscription box companies to check out.

What Is a Dog Subscription Box?

A dog subscription box is a recurring monthly delivery of dog goodies—typically toys, treats, and chews—shipped to your door. You subscribe once, choose your dog’s size and preferences, and then a curated box shows up each month as a surprise.

Most dog subscription box companies let you:

  • Choose your dog’s size (small, medium, large, or extra large)
  • Note allergies or dietary needs
  • Pick a plan length (month-to-month or 3, 6, 12 months)
  • Pause or cancel when you need to

You’re essentially outsourcing the shopping and curation to experts so your dog gets high-quality, often themed or seasonal, goodies without you wandering the pet store aisles for hours.

Why a Dog Subscription Box Is Worth Considering

Before we talk about specific USA dog subscription box brands, let’s talk benefits. Why not just grab random toys and treats at your local store?

1. Built-in Enrichment and Variety

Dogs need mental stimulation as much as physical exercise. A dog subscription box usually includes toys with different textures, sounds, and play styles (tug, fetch, chew, puzzle). This built-in variety helps keep your dog from getting bored and turning to less desirable “hobbies,” like chewing shoes or the corner of your couch.

2. Budget-Friendly Compared to Buying À La Carte

It’s easy to walk out of a pet store $60–$80 lighter after a couple of toys and premium treats. Many dog subscription boxes promise a retail value higher than what you pay monthly. For example, BarkBox says each box has over $40 worth of toys and treats for a lower subscription cost.

You’re pre-committing to a curated selection, which often means more value for your money.

3. Customization for Chewers, Allergies, and Life Stage

A big perk of a dog subscription box is customization:

  • Heavy chewers can choose boxes designed for tough jaws and power chewers.
  • Dogs with allergies or sensitivities can avoid proteins like chicken or beef.
  • Puppies can receive age-appropriate toys and even training tips.

Instead of guessing which products are safe and appropriate, the subscription box company does the research and testing.

4. The Joy of a Monthly Surprise

Let’s be honest: the human unboxing experience is half the fun. A dog subscription box turns an ordinary afternoon into a mini celebration. Your dog learns that the box means fun, and you get that feel-good “present in the mail” moment without leaving home.

Things to Consider Before Choosing a Dog Subscription Box

Not every dog subscription box will be perfect for every pup. Here are a few practical questions to think through.

1. What’s Your Dog’s Chewing Style?

  • Gentle to moderate chewers: Can handle plush toys and squeakers.
  • Aggressive chewers: Need boxes that advertise durable, power-chewer toys.

If your dog can shred a plush toy in 30 seconds, you’ll be happier with a dog subscription box made for strong jaws.

2. Does Your Dog Have Food Allergies?

If your pup can’t tolerate certain proteins or grains, look for:

  • Boxes that let you exclude specific proteins (like beef or chicken).
  • Boxes with grain-free treats.

If you’re really treat-picky, choose a box that offers toys-only options or lets you customize.

3. What’s Your Budget?

Most dog subscription boxes offer a discount if you choose longer plans (3, 6, or 12 months) instead of month-to-month. For example, Bullymake offers lower per-month pricing if you commit to several months at a time.

Decide whether you want to test a single month first or jump into a longer plan for savings.

4. How Many Toys and Treats Does Your Dog Actually Use?

A dog subscription box sounds fun, but if you’re tripping over a mountain of toys by month three, it might be time to pause or switch to a more minimal plan. Many companies allow you to skip a month or change what’s in your box (e.g., toys only).

Top Dog Subscription Box Companies to Check Out

All the brands below are USA-based dog subscription box companies that ship within the United States and focus on toys, treats, or both.

1. BarkBox – The Classic Dog Subscription Box

BarkBox is one of the most well-known dog subscription box companies in the USA. Each monthly box includes themed toys and treats, with fun collections like seasonal holidays and pop-culture collaborations.

What’s inside a typical BarkBox:

  • 2 unique toys designed in-house at BARK in New York
  • 2 full-size bags of treats made with proteins sourced in the USA
  • 1 all-natural chew

Standout features:

  • Themed boxes: Every month has a different theme, such as travel, holidays, or quirky characters, which keeps it fresh.
  • Customization: You can choose your dog’s size and exclude certain proteins if your dog has allergies.
  • Super Chewer option: For heavy chewers, the Super Chewer box includes tougher toys built for durability.

If you want a playful, themed dog subscription box that feels like a party in a package, BarkBox is a strong starting point.

2. Super Chewer by BARK – For Heavy-Duty Chewers

While technically part of the Bark family, Super Chewer deserves its own spotlight if your dog turns plush toys into fluff explosions. Super Chewer is a dog subscription box specifically created for heavy chewers.

What makes Super Chewer different:

  • Tough rubber and nylon toys designed to stand up to stronger jaws
  • Chews and treats that match the theme of each month
  • Free replacements if your dog destroys a toy too quickly (subject to their guarantee)

If your dog has already proven they can obliterate most store-bought toys, this USA-based dog subscription box is built for them.

3. PupBox – The Puppy Training Dog Subscription Box

PupBox is tailored to puppies and young dogs, with guidance and gear for each stage of puppyhood. Each box is customized based on your pup’s age, size, and stage.

What’s inside PupBox:

  • Age-appropriate toys for teething, play, and training
  • Treats and chews suitable for puppies
  • Accessories like grooming tools or training essentials
  • Training guides to help you navigate each month of puppyhood

Why PupBox stands out as a dog subscription box for puppies:

  • Boxes change as your dog grows—from teething toys for young pups to more durable, interactive toys for adolescent dogs.
  • The training tips help new pet parents feel more confident, especially during those wild puppy months.

If you’re a first-time dog owner or have a brand-new puppy, this dog subscription box gives you structure and support in addition to fun goodies.

4. Bullymake – A Dog Subscription Box for Power Chewers

Bullymake is a USA-based dog subscription box focused on power chewers. Their toys are built with tough materials, and they offer treats made in the USA with grain-free recipes.

What’s in a Bullymake box:

  • 2–3 durable toys (often nylon or rubber) designed for strong chewers
  • 2–3 bags of treats or chews (you can opt for toys-only if you prefer)

Key features:

  • Made in the USA: Their toughest toys and all of their treats are made in the USA, which can be important if you care about sourcing.
  • Custom preferences: You share your dog’s weight, allergies, and toy preferences so the box can be tailored to your dog’s play style.
  • Multi-month savings: Bullymake offers lower pricing per month for longer commitments, similar to many other subscription services.

For bulldogs, pit mixes, shepherds, and any dog that chews like it’s a job, Bullymake is one of the strongest USA dog subscription boxes on the market.

5. Other USA Dog Subscription Box Options to Explore

In addition to the big names, there are several smaller or more niche dog subscription box brands based in the USA that focus on different values—like natural ingredients, eco-friendly products, or minimal packaging. Many of these get highlighted in roundups from pet-focused media outlets and reviewers, which can be a great starting point for comparing options.

Some things you might look for as you explore:

  • Boxes that emphasize single-ingredient treats
  • Options for sensitive stomachs
  • Boxes that donate a portion of profits to shelters or rescues
  • Eco-friendly or plastic-reduced packaging

Here are a few more USA-based dog subscription box services you might want to check out — including some less obvious or boutique-style ones.

The Animal Rescue Site — Giving Back Through Subscriptions

The Animal Rescue Site isn’t a traditional “toy and treat” box company the way some subscription services are — but it’s worth mentioning if you care about rescue and charity. The organization supports animal rescue efforts and often promotes pet-friendly initiatives.

Even if The Animal Rescue Site doesn’t offer a monthly box full of toys/treats like toy-box services, many dog owners use it in combination with a subscription service — so they’re both spoiling their pets and supporting animal welfare.

If you want your dog goodies and want to support rescue efforts, pairing a dog subscription box with donations or purchases through The Animal Rescue Site can be a meaningful approach.

PupJoy — Highly Customizable, Boutique-Style Dog Subscription Box

PupJoy stands out among dog subscription box services for how customizable and curated it is.

What makes PupJoy special:

  • They offer a “build-your-own” box model — you decide what goes in: toys, treats, chews, accessories, etc.
  • Multiple “flavors” of boxes: from plush toys to durable chew toys, treat-heavy boxes, or mixed boxes.
  • Focus on high-quality, artisan goods — often from smaller or boutique makers, rather than mass-produced pet-store items.
  • Flexible subscription frequency: you can often choose monthly, bi-monthly, or quarterly delivery depending on your needs.
  • Transparent and “full-size” items (not small samples), and often treats/togs produced in the USA or sourced responsibly.

If you care about quality, want control, and maybe want to support small sellers or boutique pet-product makers — PupJoy is a dog subscription box worth checking out. Read this review!

Pooch Perks — Budget-Focused, Customizable Dog Subscription Box

If you’re looking for a lower-cost entry into the world of dog subscription boxes without sacrificing fun, Pooch Perks is a solid contender. Their boxes are designed to deliver value while still giving your dog a treat.

Why Pooch Perks works:

  • They offer different box tiers: from a simpler “Popular Pooch” to a more expansive “Pampered Pooch,” depending on what you want to spend.
  • Boxes typically include toys (plush or durable), treats, chews — sometimes even accessories or extras.
  • Customization: you select your dog’s size and can often choose toy-type (plush vs durable), and sometimes choose “toys only” if you don’t want treats.
  • Affordable price point compared to many bigger-box subscriptions — good for owners on a budget or for dogs that don’t get through toys quickly.

For value-conscious dog parents, Pooch Perks can be an easy way to give your dog monthly surprises without breaking the bank.

Always double-check that the dog subscription box you choose is clearly USA-based and that treats are sourced and produced with standards you’re comfortable with.

How to Choose the Best Dog Subscription Box for Your Pup

Now that you know some of the best USA dog subscription box companies, let’s walk through the decision-making process so you can pick a box that fits your dog and your budget.

Step 1: Match the Box to Your Dog’s Age

  • Puppy: Prioritize a box like PupBox that includes training support and puppy-safe toys.
  • Adult dog: BarkBox and Bullymake are great choices depending on whether your dog is a moderate or heavy chewer.
  • Senior dog: Look for softer treats and gentle toys; some boxes let you customize or mention special needs in your dog’s profile.

Step 2: Decide on Treat Preferences

  • Do you want treats in every box?
  • Are you okay with grain-free formulas or specific proteins?
  • Would you rather opt for toys only, especially if your dog has a very restricted diet?

Check the FAQs and customization options for each dog subscription box to make sure their treat philosophy aligns with your dog’s needs.

Step 3: Set a Monthly Budget

Compare:

  • Monthly cost versus retail value
  • Discounts for multi-month plans
  • Shipping fees (many USA dog subscription boxes offer free shipping within the contiguous U.S.)

This will help you figure out whether a higher-priced dog subscription box is still a good value once you factor in the toys and treats you’d otherwise buy individually.

Step 4: Read Reviews and Look at Past Boxes

Most companies show examples of past boxes and themes so you can see the style of toys and treats you’ll receive. Bullymake, for instance, highlights past monthly boxes by theme on their site so you can get a feel for what’s included.

Seeing actual past boxes helps you answer questions like:

  • Do these toys look fun for my dog’s play style?
  • Are the treats the kind I’d feel comfortable feeding my dog?
  • Is the overall style cute and fun (if that matters to you—no judgment if it does)?

Tips for Getting the Most Out of Your Dog Subscription Box

Once you sign up for a dog subscription box, here are some ways to make the experience even better for both you and your pup.

1. Introduce Toys One at a Time

Instead of dumping all the new toys on the floor at once, introduce them gradually:

  • Give one toy right away for an “unboxing celebration.”
  • Rotate the others in over the next few weeks.

This keeps each toy feeling like a special novelty and can help them last longer.

2. Use Treats for Training Moments

Use the treats from your dog subscription box as part of your training routine:

  • Practice recall, sit, stay, and tricks.
  • Use them for enrichment toys or puzzle feeders.

This turns your monthly box into both fun and structure—especially helpful with high-energy dogs and puppies.

3. Store Extras in a “Dog Goodies Bin”

If your dog already has plenty of toys, create a storage bin or basket for extras:

  • Rotate old toys out and new toys in.
  • Donate gently used toys your dog didn’t love to friends or local rescues (if they accept them).

A simple system will keep your home from feeling like a toy explosion while still taking advantage of everything your dog subscription box offers.

4. Communicate With Customer Support

Most USA dog subscription box companies encourage feedback. If:

  • A toy wasn’t durable enough
  • Your dog had a reaction to a treat
  • The box didn’t feel like a good match

Reach out to customer support. Companies like BARK emphasize satisfaction guarantees and will often replace items or adjust your dog’s profile going forward.

Is a Dog Subscription Box Right for You?

A dog subscription box can be a great choice if:

  • You like the idea of a fun surprise each month
  • You want curated, themed toys and treats without doing hours of research
  • Your dog benefits from having new enrichment activities regularly
  • You appreciate USA-based companies that focus on quality, sourcing, and thoughtful design

On the other hand, you might skip or pause a dog subscription box if:

  • Your dog has extremely limited dietary options and you don’t want treats in the box
  • You prefer to shop for specific toys locally
  • Your budget is very tight right now (many boxes still let you cancel or pause, so you can always come back later)

Final Thoughts – Treating Your Dog (and Yourself) with a Dog Subscription Box

At the end of the day, a dog subscription box is more than just toys and treats—it’s a monthly ritual of joy. Your dog learns that the box means playtime, you get the satisfaction of seeing them happy, and your pet-parent life feels a little easier because someone else is doing the curating.

Whether you choose a playful classic like BarkBox, a power-chewer favorite like Bullymake, or a puppy-focused option like PupBox, sticking with USA-based dog subscription box companies gives you added peace of mind when it comes to quality and sourcing.

See our Guide to Home Decor Subscription Boxes for mamas to receive surprise boxes too!

Similar Posts